Independent school tuition has been rapidly increasing at a faster rate than inflation over the past 10 years.
Mark J. Mitchell, Vice President of Financial Aid Services, NAIS, asked his audience, “Is financial aid
keeping pace, so that you can maintain socio-economic diversity at your school?” His answer is, “Yes and
no.” Schools are giving more money, but it is allocated to the same percentage of students. This is one of
the primary dilemmas in financial aid; when your funds are limited, do you give more aid to fewer students,
or less aid to more students? Ideally, you’d all like to give more aid to more students.
This workshop centered on affordability. Mark deftly demonstrated how even top income earners need
aid to pay today’s tuition bills. The affordability range charts, Figures A and B below (handouts for this
workshop), show median tuitions for day and boarding schools using SSS methodology. The “full need
income” column shows the income at which a family would have to start paying something. Anyone
earning less than this amount ($46,240 on the first chart) would pay nothing, and anyone who earns
over that amount can pay something. The “no need income” columns show what a family’s income
would have to be in order for either one or two children to not need any aid whatsoever. As you can see,
those numbers are very high. Families who earn under these amounts will be eligible for some amount
of aid. You can use COMP*ASSIST to make this simulation for your school.
Using Figure C for what is middle income, Mark next explained that the highlighted third-fifth band is statistically
middle income nationwide (approximately $42K-$65K). Look at the start of the highest income level, $98,200, and
compare that to the “no need income” columns on the previous charts, and you will see that most people don’t have
the money. Mark points out that only 17.7% of the population earns $100K+, which means 83% should qualify for aid.
So, the important question is: what proportion of this 83% is being squeezed out of your school due to affordability
issues? Even in New York City this is a top-level income, with only a little over 20% earning more than $100K per
year. The bottom line is that no matter where you live, those who make $100K+ are in the top strata of the income
range. Resources are available to research these concerns at your school. Not noted on that list, though, is Mark’s
single favorite source of data, The American Community Survey at the US Census Bureau’s website.
|